Falkirk FC AGM: Club chiefs ‘report’ Falkirk Foundation to charity regulator
Falkirk FC AGM: Club chiefs ‘report’ Falkirk Foundation to charity regulator amid disputes.
Falkirk FC’s board of directors have revealed why they felt it necessary to cut ties with former charity partner, the Falkirk Foundation.
The Falkirk Herald revealed last month that the club had split from the organisation, with a number of wide-ranging disputes leading to a point of no return.
And club chiefs have now hit back, outlining why they had “lost confidence in the foundation’s leadership.”
Falkirk FC ‘report’ Falkirk foundation
In a statement provided after the club’s recent AGM, a spokesperson for the Bairns said: “After more than four years of trying to resolve serious disagreements, we lost confidence in the Foundation’s leadership as a reliable partner for the club.
“We know how much its programmes mean to local families and value the work of the staff and volunteers who deliver them. If the only consideration was these programmes, we wouldn’t be where we are now.
“Supporters deserve to hear what the club did to try to resolve the issues before taking this decision.
“The community pitch is the biggest issue. It sits on land the club occupies under a ground lease. Our position is that no sub-lease to the foundation exists and that an income sharing agreement was an essential, constituent part of an intention to lease. Consequently, the club has been denied significant income it was entitled to receive during its most difficult years. We began trying to resolve this in 2022 holding direct talks, offered independent mediation and – twice – proposed binding arbitration.
It said the foundation’s leadership declined those offers, and the club was willing to let an independent third party decide the issue and to accept the outcome.
It added: “We would not have been in this position had mediation or arbitration been accepted.
“We also offered a way forward on the proposed community hub. The plans raised concerns about the use of club utilities without our agreement and potential impact on a future fourth stand.
In October 2024, directors met the foundation and the principal funders to explore making the hub the first stage of a fourth stand development. The Scottish FA confirmed that this could meet its funding criteria. The club was willing to work on that option, but the foundation chose to pursue its original proposal.
“To be clear: the Foundation has the grant funding, land lease, and planning permission to build its hub and remains solely responsible for the success or failure of that project.
“The hub would likely have been constructed by now had the Foundation agreed to work with us in 2024.
“There were separate questions about the Foundation’s access to the KM7 Stand, where in 2022, it said that the grant terms were included in the stand’s deeds. This turned out to be inaccurate, which we found out when the club purchased the stand.
“Having incurred significant cost in acquiring the KM7 Stand, we obviously require a return on that investment. The ,however, repeatedly asked to see the grant terms so we could understand the foundation’s claims about access, which were repeated at the AGM but again without evidence.
“The club did offer the foundation charity hire rates for its activities in the KM7 Stand and free use for the Blind Club but received no meaningful engagement, and the foundation chose to make other arrangements.
“Again, as we have already done with the tickets for carers’ tickets scheme formerly administered by the foundation, the club is open to working with community groups who want to work directly with us rather than via a third party.
“Despite the disputes, the club permitted controlled use of our trademark over the years and throughout the negotiations to avoid disruption to the Foundation’s commercial community football programmes. The foundation failed to comply with our instruction on permitted use despite repeated requests, then filed its own trademark incorporating the club’s badge without our knowledge or consent.
“Had the disputes been resolved and the foundation leadership respected the club’s requests about use of our identity, the programmes may still have operated with the club’s badge, strip and endorsement.”
The club said it proposed an “orderly separation” between the two in August, and said it was “disappointed” the foundation had spoken publicly via the Falkirk Herald.
It continued: “Supporters and shareholders entrust the board with decisions about who represents Falkirk FC and who can use its name and badge. After years of talks and offers to resolve disputes independently, we concluded that we no longer had the confidence to give the foundation our endorsement or recommend it to Falkirk supporters and their families.”
The club denied its decision was motivated by money.
“The board takes responsibility for the decision we have taken,” a statement read. “Consulting fans on the decision would have meant presenting disputed, complex, and legally sensitive information in the public domain which would have been divisive and inappropriate. Our attempts to resolve our disagreements directly and by independent third parties were rejected.
“We have submitted our concerns and supporting evidence to the Scottish charity regulator and are consulting Scottish football’s governing bodies. Some matters remain disputed, and we will deal with them through the appropriate processes.
“Falkirk FC has no influence over the foundation’s activities, and hasn’t for some years. They are free to continue their charity and paid football work, like any other charity, but without any formal relationship with the football club. We wish the staff, volunteers, and users of these services the very best.”
The foundation has already issued its own correspondence, saying that they felt it was “important to clarify a number of issues and to correct information that it consider inaccurate or misleading.”
In that statement, they said that “disagreements had arisen concerning the Foundation’s independence, access to facilities, the use of the club’s branding and the development of the planned community hub.”
Falkirk fourth stand dispute continues
Regarding the club’s fourth stand ambition, the foundation stressed that the community hub project would not prevent Falkirk FC from completing the stadium.
Its website continued: “The Hope Street Hub has secured planning permission, building approvals and substantial external funding. As a modular building, it can easily be relocated should there be a new development plan for the site.
“We recognise and support the club’s ambitions to develop Falkirk Stadium. However, the possibility of a fourth stand at some point in the future should not, in itself, prevent an approved and funded community development from proceeding today.”
The Falkirk Herald has approached the foundation for further comment.
Speaking at the club’s AGM, director Keith Gourlay challenged the foundation’s initial statement provided to the Falkirk Herald, and the subsequent material published online.
He described the foundation’s published material as “narrow and selective”, going on to say that the club is considering reporting the foundation’s statements to the Scottish FA.
The club chief also said that the Bairns had ‘already reported’ the foundation to the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR).
The Falkirk Herald has approached OSCR for comment.
