XV-a-Side: Wales’ big loss against Springboks 'predictable and ridiculous'
Here is this week’s XV-a-Side column, created in partnership with Rugby Memories Scotland.
LAST WEEK’S ANSWERS
The Mystery Player was John Leslie , and it was FALSE. They never played together for Scotland.
STRAIGHT TO THE POINT


I remember watching Rugby League games on TV back in the days of Eddie Waring and hearing my dad shouting at the screen in total disgust at the antics of the scrum half. Not in straight! I can hear him scream as the ball was fed straight past the front row. He played hooker in his rugby career, and shook his head as the skill of hooking and taking a ball against the head became a dying art. Today, the front row look like they are just three props whose sole function is to push. Why police every aspect of the game, with or without video assistance, yet ignore a clear and obvious instance of law infringement?
A RUNNING GAME NO MORE
When South Africa announced seven forwards and one three-quarter on their bench, you could have written the script. At times it resembled the Orcs army from Lord of the Rings. Power, strength, and an aim of running over the opposition. It was brutal, uncompromising, and ruthless. If this is what the future of professional rugby looks like, then something has been lost. The game that gave us players like Duckham, Hastings, Gibson, Blanco, Edwards, John, and their like is a million miles away from this.
THIS WEEK’S FIXTURES
Falkirk are up in Inverness to play Highland with their 2s at home to Kinross.
Grangemouth 1s play Howe of Fife in Cupar,
Linlithgow 1s are at home to Dunfermline with their seconds playing the Ayr 2A team.
LAST WEEK’S RESULTS
Falkirk 1s beat bottom side Berwick 55-17. Dunfermline 2s were unable to field a side against Grangemouth 2s. Grangemouth Women beat Broughton 27-22 in an exciting game through in Edinburgh. Linlithgow 1s beat Whitecraigs 34-27 in Newton Mearns.
In the URC, Edinburgh beat a spirited Ospreys side 19-17, while an off-form Glasgow went down 23-0 to Scarlets to give the Welsh side their first win of the season.
VALUE FOR MONEY?
Red Bull’s massive financial investment in Newcastle looks less than a wise move. Expensive recruitment of overseas players and coaching staff, not to mention “advisers” such as Gregor Townsend, has produced six defeats from six games and a team that is eight points adrift in the table.
WALES 0 SOUTH AFRICA 73
Predictable and ridiculous. A match that should never have been staged. What good did that do for the players of either side? The Welsh Rugby Union should hang their heads in shame. South Africa’s Eben Etzebeth was rightly sent off for that eye gouge, and he deserves a lengthy ban. “The optics weren’t great” was the verdict of the Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus and that must go down as the understatement of the year.
MYSTERY PLAYER
Who is this Scotland forward?
TRUE OR FALSE?
Our Mystery Player was a major in the Royal Army Medical Corps.