Ten-year masterplan for Bo'ness' Kinneil Estate approved despite concerns it "needs more work"
A 10-year masterplan to improve and protect one of the Falkirk area’s most historic parks has been approved by councillors, despite criticism that it “lacks substance and needs more work”.
Falkirk Council say the masterplan provides a vision to develop the 76-hectare estate Kinneil Estate in Bo’ness, starting with a new playpark and including major work on the woodland surrounding the estate.


But the charity Friends of Kinneil urged members of Falkirk Council’s executive not to approve the plan until there is more detail on how facilities, including toilets, will be provided.
Kinneil Estate is much loved as an outdoor space by Bo’ness residents.
But it also has a heritage that stretches back to Roman times and is linked to major historical figures from Mary Queen of Scots to the inventor James Watt.
The estate includes the 17th century Kinneil House which contains rare Renaissance wall paintings and is now managed by Historic Environment Scotland (HSE).
Friends of Kinneil believe that the estate has the potential to be a major magnet for tourists, adding to other local attractions including Bo’ness and Kinneil Railway.
The estate also includes Kinneil Museum, which is owned by Falkirk Council but will close in March as part of the council’s ongoing property review, unless a third party agrees to take it over.
The council says that the masterplan has been shaped by consultation with local residents, community groups and others.
But Friends of Kinneil’s former chair, Ian Shearer, told the meeting that the consultation had shown quite clearly that the facilities in the visitor centre are needed “and should be an essential element of the plan”.
Last week news of a £200,000 upgrade to the playpark on the estate, funded by the Scottish Government, was widely welcomed.
Mr Shearer said: “With all the talk in the plan of new visitors, including at the new playpark, which we do think looks very good – where will they go to the toilet or get refreshments?”
He added that talks have been ongoing with Historic Environment Scotland and Museums Galleries Scotland to find a way forward for the museum but they have not yet reached any conclusions.
Separately “an impressive third-party investor” is “working up some serious proposals” for the currently empty main block of Kinneil House.
These proposals, he said “could form the core of a much more inspiring ten-year plan than the one before you”.
He said that with so much still to be decided, councillors were effectively being asked to “endorse a 10-year visitor roadmap, whilst blindfolded as you set off and with little idea where the route is leading”.
Mr Shearer also criticised the lack of funding behind the plan, especially in light of imminent proposals for Callendar Park and the Helix Park, both in Falkirk.
But director of Place Services Malcolm Bennie told councillors that delaying the masterplan could jeopardise funding applications, including one to maintain and improve the woodlands.
He said that it had been ‘heavily consulted’ and that many different groups and individuals supported it.
Michael McGuinness, the council’s head of growth, planning and climate change, added that approving a plan would be helpful to any future transfer of the museum to a community group or organisation such as HES.
He said: “The plan gives certainty to any group who’s considering what’s going on across the estate, what other investments are going to be made, what other initiatives and opportunities are going on.”
At Thursday’s meeting, Labour councillor Siobhan Paterson’s bid to delay the approval of the masterplan was narrowly defeated and councillors agreed to back the masterplan.
Following the decision at last week’s meeting, a spokesperson for Friends of Kinneil said: “We are disappointed by the adoption of this underwhelming document. It is supposed to be a 10-year roadmap for development, but it lacks substance, firm commitments and adequate investment proposals relative to places of comparable value and their similar plans.
“There were clear concerns in the meeting about its weaknesses and that its contents and stated aims do not hang together coherently. We are grateful for the opportunity to explain the issues publicly, and to those who supported and shared these reservations.
“Despite the endorsement of the report, Councillors across all parties did seem to agree that it is now even more important to save existing visitor facilities and follow through on the stated aim to improve them. We are asking the Council to continue to work in partnership with Historic Environment Scotland and others to save the museum visitor centre, and further develop Kinneil as a whole as an historic attraction.
“This will build on other recent enhancements, which we do welcome, such as the proposed large new play area announced this week. Retention and improvement of the visitor centre would also provide essential complementary visitor facilities such as toilets and refreshments, and lead a way to an overall visitor experience which matches Kinneil’s potential and historic significance”.