Report finds Maddiston Primary builder to blame for faults - but Falkirk Council supervision was 'inadequate'
A report into serious defects at a Falkirk area primary school which led to its ongoing closure has found that while the construction company was at fault, the council’s supervision of the project was “inadequate”.
Structural problems affecting Maddiston Primary School were discovered following Storm Eowyn in January 2025, when an inspection of damage revealed widespread hidden defects that have left Falkirk Council facing a £14 million repair bill.
In June 2025, the council’s executive commissioned an independent Root Cause Analysis from Glenmhor Property Consultants in a bid to understand what went wrong, who was responsible and what needs done to prevent the situation happening again.
The report – to be discussed by members of the council’s executive on May 21 – says the building company, Graham Construction, was “primarily responsible for the poor construction quality”.


It states: “It is clear that the terms of the construction contract and standard construction management practices at the time were not adhered to by Graham Construction, their subcontractors and technical professionals.”
But the review also found a lack of supervision by council staff who should have been overseeing the project, saying “the council’s governance arrangements and management approach including site supervision, construction quality practices, and overall management (including record keeping) were inadequate”.
It states: “Many of the resulting defects could have been avoided had appropriate diligence, robust quality assurance and effective oversight been applied.”
The council’s building standards department also comes in for criticism as its officers should have verified that the construction complied with building regulations at the time.


The report says: “It has been identified that despite engagement across services at the time and the subsequent occupation of the school neither a completion certificate, nor a record of any temporary occupation certificate being requested or issued.”
However, since the work was completed in 2007, the report highlights this means that many of those involved in key stages “cannot be definitively identified”.
But the consultants did identify that problems with the build began at an early stage, with unresolved issues even after construction had started.
A fire at the newly-constructed school in 2007 led to a lengthy delay in pupils finally getting into their classrooms with the £9 million building opening in August 2008.
There were also three changes in the architect/contract administrator roles during the construction period, which “disrupted continuity and delayed the production and coordination of design information”.
Glenmhor noted that the “level of presence and recorded intervention by the clerk of works in the early stages of the project appears limited given the number and seriousness of issues being raised”.
It also reports that several concerns were raised by the structural engineer during the build but Glenmhor did not have access to engineering certificates confirming that all these issues were satisfactorily resolved.
None of the council officers responsible for overseeing the construction work are still with the council.
But according to this latest report – which initially had been due in January – “lessons have been learned” and new procedures introduced to ensure a similar situation is not repeated.
This include a pledge to employ a full-time clerk of works for major projects and training for staff.
The council has also sought to assured parents that it has already carried out condition surveys at all schools, including intrusive surveys of similar external walls with minor works undertaken where issues were identified.
According to the new report, Falkirk Council officers, supported by external legal advisers, are now engaging with Graham Construction and will continue to assess legal action to be taken.
While part of the building is again being used, the report confirms that the school can be reinstated, subject to significant remedial works, with d a projected completion date of August 2027.
Malcolm Bennie, director of place services, said: “This is an important report for the council in terms of transparency of what went wrong with the original construction of the school, lessons learned, and most importantly reassuring parents and our communities about the safety of our school estate.
“The review highlights that the original construction of Maddiston Primary School around 2007 fell well short of the standards that pupils, parents and the council should have been able to rely on.
“As soon as these defects were identified, we acted to close the school and we have subsequently checked the rest of the school estate to provide reassurance to families.
“It is essential that we learn everything we can from this situation, and I’m reassured to see that the changes described in this report show the Council has already changed how we manage construction projects, to ensure this does not happen again.
