XV-a-Side: Stick or twist... is time up for Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend

Here is this week’s XV-a-Side column, created in partnership with Rugby Memories Scotland.

LAST WEEK’S ANSWERS

MYSTERY PLAYER: Who is this ex-Scotland forward? (Photo: SNS Group)placeholder image
MYSTERY PLAYER: Who is this ex-Scotland forward? (Photo: SNS Group)

The Mystery Player was Mark Ella , and it was TRUE. He is a member of the IRB Hall of Fame.

STICK OR TWIST?

Scotland’s collapse in the game against Argentina triggered a media frenzy. Most of the blame was focused on coach Gregor Townsend and some scribes called for his resignation. With Townsend having recently signed a new contract and with a Rugby World Cup in 2027 looming large, the timing of any change would be less than ideal. Townsend himself remains convinced Scotland can go on to achieve success and described the New Zealand game as “one of the best performances we’ve seen.” Others will point to the tendency to collapse in the final stages of games and the habit of being so close to wins that slip away.

LAST WEEK’S RESULTS

Falkirk 1s beat Kirkcaldy 42-33 in an entertaining game at Sunnyside. Their 2s were heavily beaten 76-7 in a local derby at Glensburgh by a rampant home side. Grangemouth 2s also recorded a home win, beating Arbroath 44-12. Linlithgow went down 24-7 to Cartha and their 2s suffered a 45-0 defeat in Edinburgh against Heriot’s 2A XV.

AUTUMN INTERNATIONALS

Ireland’s indiscipline cost them dearly against South Africa. They were given five cards in a game best described as chaotic.

Wales managed four tries against New Zealand but went down 52-26 . There were signs of improvement in a spirited performance, and congratulations Tom Rogers -few Welshmen can say they scored a hat-trick of tries against the All Blacks. The scoreboard could hardly keep up in Paris as France beat Australia 48-33, while Italy beat Chile 34-19 in Genoa. The Chileans made Italy fight all the way in the second half. On Sunday, Scotland beat a struggling and disjointed Tonga side 56-0 and at times you could be forgiven for knowing that there was a match on. England looked to be coasting at half time with a 17-3 lead over Argentina, but the visitors came back strongly, and a nervous England held on for a narrow 27-23 win.

THIS WEEK’S FIXTURES

Falkirk 1s are at home to bottom side Berwick. Grangemouth 2s are at home to Dunfermline 2s in the Reserve Team Cup. Grangemouth Women play Broughton in Edinburgh on Sunday. Linlithgow 1s face Whitecraigs, with their 2s at home to GHK 2s.All games start at 2.00pm in the winter months.

FIRST PRIZE FOR IDIOTIC PLANNING

Step forward the Welsh Rugby Union. They agreed to play World Champions South Africa on Saturday November 29th, which is outside the international window, so they won’t be able to select thirteen players from teams outside Wales. Nor might they be able to select from their own four professional sides who will all be playing in URC league fixtures. You couldn’t make it up if you tried.

MYSTERY PLAYER

Who is this Scotland and Lions forward?

TRUE OR FALSE?

Our Mystery Player played in the same Scotland side as his brother.

News you can trust since 1845
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice